- Headnote
- Posts
- HCA hands down 4 decisions
HCA hands down 4 decisions
The High Court hands down 4 decisions and continues to hear Judge Vasta case, ASIC sues ASX, threats of HCA action re Lawyer X bill
Was this email forwarded to you?
Sign up for our free daily email newsletter at headnote.com.au
Daily wrap
Judgment summaries for the decisions handed down by the HCA yesterday are below:
Edelman J [198] “…These are civil appeals. But the principles concerned have far-reaching consequences through both civil and criminal law in these two areas.”
Edelman J [239] “…Just as a team playing a game "cannot be reduced to the personal acts of the players"[230]—a behind can be scored by the Fremantle Dockers if the ball was rushed through the goal by the opposition rather than being kicked by any of the Dockers' great players—so too legal rules can provide that a corporation acted even if the action cannot be attributed to the corporation from a single individual.”
CBI Constructors Pty Ltd v Chevron Australia Pty Ltd [2024] HCA 28 (14 August 2024)
Steven Moore (a pseudonym) v The King [2024] HCA 30 (14 August 2024)
24-177MR ASIC sues ASX for alleged misleading statements | ASIC
ASIC needs ‘eat-what-you-kill’ resources [The Australian paywall]
The corporate regulator should be able to bank any winnings it gets from its successful litigation, according to experts.
High Court threat over ‘outrageous’ move to block Lawyer X compensation [The Age paywall]
Lawyers warn an “outrageous” state government move to protect itself from compensation claims connected with Nicola Gobbo, the barrister turned police informer, is undemocratic and unjust, and could face a High Court challenge.
Melbourne barrister charged with trafficking and possessing drugs [The Age paywall]
Lawyer Anthony Grant is facing a significant amount of time behind bars for allegedly trafficking a commercial quantity of illicit drugs in Melbourne.
Former DPP seeks rethink on drug laws [The Australian paywall]
Former head prosecutor Nicholas Cowdery has called for an expansion of the drug courts and an overhaul of possession laws as NSW lags behind the country.
Editor’s picks
What subjects can the Commonwealth make laws about? - Anne Twomey - YouTube
This video explains how legislative power is distributed between the Commonwealth and State Parliaments by the Commonwealth Constitution. It discusses why the power to make laws about certain types of subjects was conferred on the Commonwealth Parliament. It addresses the different categories of heads of legislative power and where they are to be found in the Constitution. It briefly discusses how expansive judicial interpretation has affected the scope of heads of legislative power and how Commonwealth laws frequently rely upon a patchwork of different heads of power, potentially leaving gaps in the law.
Chief Magistrate to debate intersection of courts and journalism - Law Society Journal
7 Partners Defect from Australia’s Corrs to King & Wood Mallesons | Law.com International [paywall]
Victorian Legal Services Commissioner v O'Brien (Legal Practice) [2024] VCAT 756 (9 August 2024)
[10] Some of the charges in this proceeding also concern undoubtedly inappropriate communications Mr O’Brien sent to State Trustees Limited (STL) between 2017 and 2018, and to the Commissioner between 2017 and 2021.
[11] Several of them are disgraceful. They included: an email to STL describing the VCAT member who presided over a guardianship hearing as a ‘bitch’ who he was going to ‘destroy’; and an email to the [Victorian Legal Services] Commissioner in which he wrote:
the gatekeepers controlling entry to my profession have failed to keep out the trash and they should, each and every one, be shot, ideally with a small calibre pistol to the back of the head. If this should become legal, you might let me know, because I will happily cooperate with and perform the necessaries. This was the preferred method adopted by Josif Vissarionovich Dzhugashvili (don’t “google” it – he’s better known as Stalin), and it was very effective.
JK Rowling and Elon Musk named in Imane Khelif cyberbullying lawsuit | France | The Guardian
If I had my time over, would I study Law?
In this Lecture, the Hon Linda Dessau AC CVO, former Governor of Victoria, weighs the pros and cons of dedicating a significant part of her career to Law.
Tap through to register → unimelb.me/3WKdh2c
— Melbourne Law School (@MelbLawSchool)
2:32 AM • Aug 14, 2024
State Civil Liability (Police Informants) Bill 2024 now up: legislation.vic.gov.au/bills/state-ci….
Includes a Charter dis-application section:
— Jeremy Gans (@jeremy_gans)
2:36 AM • Aug 14, 2024
CJ: Mr Herzfeld, at some stage I would be assisted by your analysis of the case of Plaintiff M61/2010.
MR HERZFELD: I remember M61 vividly. I suspect your Honour might as well.
CJ: I suspect I remember it more vividly than you. [a loss for the then S-G, on a hot topic]
1/3— High Court (Australia) Trivia (@HighCourtTrivia)
8:13 AM • Aug 14, 2024
The High Court will tomorrow continue hearing the matters of State of Queensland v Mr Stradford (A Pseudonym); Commonwealth of Australia v Mr Stradford (A Pseudonym); His Honour Judge Salvatore Paul Vasta v Mr Stradford (A Pseudonym) hcourt.gov.au/assets/registr…
— High Court of Australia (@HighCourtofAus)
8:23 AM • Aug 14, 2024
We welcome your feedback, which you can send to [email protected]